Soft vs Hard Roof Top Carrier: What to Choose?

Roofpax Soft vs Hard Roof Top Carrier

When expanding a car's storage capacity, car bags offer a convenient solution. But choosing between a soft or hard product can be challenging. Each option comes with its set of advantages and considerations. They can greatly impact your experience.

Soft car top carriers are typically made from durable fabric. Those are nylon or polyester. And they offer flexibility, affordability, and easy storage when not in use. They are lightweight and often designed to fit various car sizes and shapes. Hard ones are made with rigid content like plastic or fibreglass. It provides good protection against harsh weather conditions. 

We’ll explore the key factors to consider when choosing soft vs hard rooftop carriers. We will examine their features, benefits, drawbacks, and compatibility with your needs. And you'll be better equipped to make an informed decision. And you'll select the product that best suits your requirements.

Soft vs Hard Roof Top Carrier Difference

Understanding the differences between types of car gabs is crucial. Soft ones are known for their lightweight and flexible design. At the same time, hard products offer increased durability and security. 

Each type has its distinct features and benefits. It can greatly influence your choice depending on your specific needs and preferences. You can make an informed decision by examining the contrasts between soft and hard roof cargo carriers. And you will ensure that your chosen product meets all your requirements.

In the following blocks of our soft vs hard roof top carrier guide, we will focus on disparities between these two types of bags. We will explore their construction, materials, advantages, and potential drawbacks. This comprehensive analysis will assist you in making the right choice for your car bag.

Construction and Content

Soft bags are typically made from durable fabric. Those are nylon or polyester. They feature a flexible construction. It allows them to fit various shapes and sizes of transported items. These products often have adjustable straps and buckles. They are great for secure attachment to the roof rack.

Hard roof cargo carriers are made using rigid content such as plastic or fibreglass. They have a sturdy design. It offers good protection for your belongings. These products are usually equipped with lockable latches or secure locking systems. But they are not very flexible.

Load Capacity

Soft bags often provide a larger capacity compared to hard shell car roof carriers. Their flexible design allows for expansion, enabling users to maximize the available space. Many soft carriers also come with adjustable straps or compression systems. It helps secure the load and prevent shifting during transportation. This flexibility and increased load capacity make soft carriers an ideal choice for:

  • Road trips.
  • Camping adventures.
  • Other activities that need carrying a significant amount of gear.

Weather Protection 

Protection against bad weather is another area where soft car top carriers excel. The materials used in their construction are typically water-resistant or waterproof. It provides a reliable barrier against rain, snow, and other environmental conditions. 

Soft bags often feature robust zippers or weatherproof flaps. They help further enhance water resistance. Also, the soft nature of these bags allows them to absorb better impacts and vibrations than hard roof cargo carriers do. It helps protect the contents from damage during travel.

Aerodynamics and Fuel Efficiency

As for aerodynamics and fuel efficiency, soft bags have a clear advantage over hard ones. The sleek and streamlined design of soft bags creates less wind resistance compared to the bulkier and box-like shape of hard roof cargo carriers.

This reduced drag minimizes the impact on the vehicle's fuel efficiency. It results in potential fuel savings during long trips. The aerodynamic advantage of soft carriers also translates to reduced wind noise. It provides a more comfortable and quieter ride for passengers.

Storage and Portability

One of the advantages of soft car top carriers is their collapsible and lightweight nature. They can be easily folded or rolled up when unused. It allows for convenient storage in small spaces. Additionally, their light weight makes them easier to handle during installation or removal.

Hard roof cargo carriers are bulkier and less flexible compared to soft ones. They need more storage space when not in use and may need to be disassembled or detached from the roof rack. 

Considering these differences will help you determine which product aligns better with your requirements.

RoofPax bag is constructed with heavy-duty, military-grade 1680D PVC fabric

Why Choose RoofPax Soft Car Top Carrier?

Hard shell car roof carrier is a good option. But RoofPax Soft Bag is a reliable and high-quality solution for everyone. Here are some reasons why you should consider choosing RoofPax:

  • Durability and Weather Resistance. RoofPax bag is constructed with heavy-duty, military-grade 1680D PVC fabric. It makes it exceptionally durable and resistant to tears, abrasions, and extreme weather. It features double-coated waterproof zippers and dual-seam technology. This ensures complete protection against rain, snow, dust, and UV rays.
  • Spacious and Secure Storage. With a generous capacity of 19 cubic feet, RoofPax provides ample room. It's designed to fit various car sizes and can accommodate bulky items. The product includes 8 Velcro straps and a protective mat. It's for secure attachment and to prevent any shifting or damage during transportation.
Find out why RoofRax car bags allow you to pack more luggage
  • Easy Installation and Versatility. RoofPax soft car top carrier can be effortlessly installed on any car. You can do it with or without a roof rack. It features a patented strap system that ensures a secure and tight fit. The product is compatible with cars, SUVs, and vans.
Learn How to Install Soft Car Top Carrier on any Car!
  • Aerodynamic Design and Fuel Efficiency. RoofPax pays attention to aerodynamics. It helps cut wind resistance and maintain fuel efficiency. The bag’s sleek design and streamlined shape reduce drag. It allows for smoother travel and better gas mileage.
  • Convenient Storage. You can fold the RoofPax soft car top carrier and compactly store it in its included storage bag when not in use. This feature makes storing the product in your garage or trunk easy without taking up much space.

Bottom Line

In conclusion of our soft vs hard rooftop carrier guide, it's essential to consider your specific needs and priorities. Soft bags offer flexibility, affordability, and easy storage. It makes them suitable for lightweight and occasional use. But a hard shell car roof carrier provides increased:

  • Durability.
  • Security.
  • Weather resistance. 

It makes them ideal for heavier loads and frequent outdoor activities.

Ultimately, you should base your decision on factors such as:

  • Load capacity.
  • Protection against the elements.
  • Aerodynamics.
  • Storage convenience.

FAQ: Soft vs Hard Roof Top Carrier

How do I choose a rooftop cargo carrier?

When choosing a rooftop cargo carrier, consider the following factors:

  • Size and capacity. 
  • Compatibility. 
  • Material and durability. Look for carriers made from durable and weather-resistant materials.
  • Security. Opt for carriers with sturdy straps, buckles, or locking mechanisms.
  • Waterproofing. 
  • Ease of Installation. 

What is a car top carrier?

It is an extra storage unit. It's mounted on the roof of a vehicle. It provides extra space for carrying luggage, equipment, or other bulky items. Car top carriers come in various shapes, sizes, and materials. They're designed to attach to the roof rack or vehicle roof securely.

How waterproof is the RoofPax soft car top carrier?

The RoofPax soft car top carrier is highly waterproof. It's constructed using heavy-duty, military-grade 1680D PVC fabric. It's known for its durability and water resistance. The carrier features double-coated waterproof zippers and a dual-seam technology. It ensures the most protection against rain, snow etc.

Are rooftop cargo carriers safe?

Rooftop cargo carriers can be safe when used properly. But it's important to follow the manufacturer's guidelines for installation and weight limits. Overloading the carrier or not securing it properly can pose safety risks. Also, be mindful of the added height and weight on the roof, as it can affect the vehicle's stability and handling.

Can I use a rooftop cargo carrier on a vehicle without a roof rack?

Yes, there are rooftop cargo carriers available that can be on vehicles without a roof rack. These carriers typically use alternative mounting systems, such as straps or hooks. They secure them directly to the vehicle roof.